| | |

Why Every Democracy Ends in Mob Rule and a Strongman — Polybius Called It 2,000 Years Ago

Why Every Democracy Ends in Mob Rule and a Strongman — Polybius Called It 2,000 Years Ago

Is Every Civilization Doomed to Fail? – Polybius

Polybius, a Greek historian held hostage in Rome, argued that every democracy ends in mob rule and a strongman. Was he right?

More than 2,000 years ago he described a cycle that every government passes through, and he warned that even Rome’s balanced constitution would wear out. This video follows his argument step by step, then watches the Roman Republic test it, from Scipio’s tears at Carthage in 146 BC to the burning of the Senate house in 52 BC and the rise of Augustus.

In this video:

• The 52 BC fire that destroyed the Roman Senate house, and why Cato backed one-man rule

• Who Polybius was: a Greek held hostage in Rome for about 17 years

• His cycle of governments, from kings and tyrants to oligarchs, democracy and mob rule

• How a bidding war for the crowd’s favour wears a democracy down

• How a crowd becomes a mob, in Mark Granovetter’s threshold model

• Rome’s mixed constitution and the checks that delayed the end

• Scipio’s tears at Carthage, the killing of Tiberius Gracchus, Clodius and Milo, Pompey and Augustus

• Bread and circuses, and whether Polybius was right about every democracy

Chapters:

0:00 The Senate Fire and the Greek Hostage

1:59 The Cycle That Ends Every Government

3:30 The Bidding War for the Crowd

5:55 How Crowds Become Mobs, and Rome’s Safeguard

10:05 When the Brake Starts to Fail

13:08 Clodius, Cato and the Burning Senate

14:51 Pompey, Caesar and Augustus

16:17 Was Polybius Right?

Which of Polybius’s warning signs is furthest along where you live: the bidding war for the crowd, forgetting what the rules are for, or the feeling that somebody has to put a stop to the chaos? And if you think he got it wrong, what did he miss? Tell me in the comments.

Watch Video:


Discover more from Truther's Journal

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Similar Posts